Andy's & Sons Importing Co. 256 Delaware Ave

It's the small details that separate an OK sub from a great sub: a roll firm enough to weather overnight in the fridge without getting hopelessly soggy, real oil and vinegar rather than cheap, over-sweet Italian salad dressing, and high-quality meat in generous, but not Viking, quantities. Andy's does it right. Not to mention they have an incredible variety of meats, cheeses, kick-ass sausage, and friendly expertise about all of the above.

I got me an All American which has ham, turkey, roast beef, cheese lettuce, onions, tomatoes but hold the tomatoes, please.